On paper, the sound profiles of the Audio-Technica ATH-AC5TW and the Shokz OpenFit 2 Plus look nearly identical: both cover the standard 20 Hz–20,000 Hz frequency range, and neither offers ANC, passive noise reduction, spatial audio, Dolby Atmos, or Dirac Virtuo processing. For open-ear earbuds, the absence of noise isolation features is expected by design — these are built for situational awareness, not acoustic sealing.
The one concrete differentiator in this group is driver size. The OpenFit 2 Plus uses a 17.3 mm driver compared to the ATH-AC5TW's 14.3 mm — a 3 mm gap that is meaningful in context. Larger drivers generally move more air, which can translate to fuller low-end response and greater overall loudness at the same power level. In open-ear form factors, where bass naturally bleeds into the environment, a bigger driver can help compensate for that inherent loss. That said, driver size alone does not guarantee superior sound — tuning matters enormously — and no additional data here confirms how each driver is tuned.
Given strictly what the specs provide, the OpenFit 2 Plus holds a narrow technical edge in this category solely on the basis of its larger driver, which offers at least the potential for more impactful sound in an open-ear configuration. The ATH-AC5TW is not at a dramatic disadvantage, but the driver size gap is the only meaningful differentiator available, and it favors the Shokz.