Rarely in a comparison does a software category land this close to a dead heat. Across a comprehensive list of app features — activity reports, inactivity alerts, calorie counting, goal setting, achievements, exercise diary, coaching, route support, music playback, widgets, personalization, water intake tracking, weight tracking, and a full suite of women's health tools including period notifications, fertile window display, ovulation prediction, and cycle start date forecasting — both watches deliver identically. The companion apps are functionally equivalent for virtually every user scenario covered by this data.
The single point of divergence is temperature tracking within the app, present on the Huawei Watch Fit 4 Pro and absent on the Redmi Watch 5. This ties directly back to the Fit 4 Pro's hardware temperature sensor noted in the sensors group — the app feature is only meaningful because the underlying hardware exists to feed it data. For users who want to monitor body temperature trends over time, such as for recovery analysis or cycle-based basal temperature charting, this is a genuine addition. The Redmi simply has no equivalent.
As software categories go, this is essentially a tie — the overlap is so extensive that for the overwhelming majority of users, both apps will feel equally capable. The Fit 4 Pro's temperature tracking app support is the only differentiator, and its value depends entirely on whether that specific data point matters to the individual user.