Both phones share the same 6.9-inch OLED/AMOLED panel and a 120Hz refresh rate, so the fundamentals of smoothness and color technology are on equal footing. The critical divergence, however, is sharpness: the Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra's 1440 x 3120 resolution at 498 ppi is substantially crisper than the Xiaomi 17 Pro Max's 1200 x 2608 at 416 ppi. That 82 ppi gap is perceptible — fine text, detailed photos, and VR-adjacent use cases will all look noticeably more refined on the S25 Ultra's display.
The Xiaomi 17 Pro Max punches back with a couple of exclusive features. It adds Dolby Vision support on top of the shared HDR10/HDR10+ compatibility, which means compatible streaming content — Netflix, Apple TV+, Disney+ — can be tone-mapped with Dolby's more dynamic grading pipeline. More distinctively, it includes a secondary screen, a feature the S25 Ultra entirely lacks; depending on its size and placement, this can add meaningful utility for notifications, widgets, or media controls without waking the main panel.
The verdict here is split by use case. For raw visual fidelity — especially for photography review, reading, or any pixel-dense content — the Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra holds a clear edge thanks to its significantly higher resolution. But the Xiaomi 17 Pro Max's Dolby Vision certification and secondary display give it a multitasking and streaming edge that some users will value more. On balance, the S25 Ultra wins the display category for most users, but the Xiaomi's additional screen is a differentiator that should not be overlooked.